How to spot fake vintage football shirts!

Identifying counterfeit vintage football shirts takes a sharp eye and a solid understanding of design, materials, and labelling from each era. Genuine shirts show accurate craftsmanship, authentic branding, and natural aging. Fakes, on the other hand, often give themselves away through poor stitching, mismatched tags, cheap fabrics, and sloppy printing.

1. Check Manufacturer and Sponsor Details

Authentic shirts feature precise embroidery and correctly aligned sponsor logos. If the logo looks crooked, pixelated, or feels like a cheap sticker rather than heat-pressed or stitched, it’s probably fake. Always verify that the brand and sponsor combination actually existed for that season — official kit archives or collector databases can confirm this.

2. Inspect Fabric and Material

Vintage kits from the 1970s to 1990s were typically made from robust polyester blends with sublimated graphics. Authentic shirts often show natural signs of age such as light fading, slight cracking, or subtle fraying. Counterfeits might appear artificially aged or, conversely, suspiciously pristine for something supposedly decades old.

3. Verify Tags and Labels

Original shirts carry era-accurate collar and wash labels with the correct fonts and manufacturer marks. Product codes didn’t become standard until the early 2000s — so shirts from before then shouldn’t have them.

For example:

  • Kappa (1990s) shirts feature a yellow triangle on the black neck label. If it’s missing, be wary. If you see the 6 diagonally aligned dots on the collar label in the triangle, this is a positive sign that the shirt is authentic.

  • Nike, Adidas, (post-2000) shirts include an easily googled product codes on their wash labels — a quick and reliable way to confirm authenticity. Adidas will have a code on the other side of the small silver label with a QR Code. Google the middle code and "adidas" and if the shirt you are researching appears then there is a very high chance it is authentic. Nike have a small label under the wash labels with a code, for example "545036-403". If you type this into Google along with the "Nike" the shirt you are researching should appear.

  • Hummel You can search the "st" reference number. For example "ST 227413 HUMMEL" and you would see the SSV Jahn Regensburg Away Jersey. 

4. Examine Branding Accuracy

Every logo, badge, and font should perfectly match official designs from that period. Look for mismatched colours, incorrect sizing, or inconsistent stitching. Any mix-up — like an Adidas logo on a Nike-tagged shirt — is a clear sign of forgery.

5. Assess Condition and Natural Aging

Authentic vintage shirts show realistic aging: faded hues, cracked sponsor prints, and gentle wear around the edges. If a supposed “vintage” shirt looks brand new, uses modern materials, or feels overly glossy, it’s likely a modern reproduction rather than an original.

6. Consider Provenance and Seller Credibility

Genuine provenance adds major credibility. Certificates of authenticity, match-worn documentation, or original packaging can help verify a shirt’s history. Purchase only from trusted specialists such as NICLASICO or retailers that come with references from friends and family. Avoid sellers with vague descriptions, bulk listings, or unrealistically low prices.

7. Compare with Trusted References

Cross-check every detail — from label placement to font style — using reputable databases like Football Kit Archive or Historical Kits. Collector forums and online communities can also help verify authenticity based on shared knowledge and reference photos.

By focusing on key details — particularly tags, materials, and provenance — you can confidently distinguish genuine vintage football shirts from fakes, ensuring your collection remains both authentic and valuable.

Back to blog